Dr. Pepper cokes, revisited

Long ago and far away, in the old blogging world, I posted about Dr. Pepper:

Any Southerner knows that if you ask someone this question:

“Would you like a coke?”

And the person to whom you are speaking replies “yes”, then the proper follow-up is:

“What kind of coke do you want?”

And the response might be “Dr. Pepper”, or “Pepsi”, or “Barq’s”, or “RC”. Or they might reply “Coke”, which then becomes contextually known to mean Coca-Cola. .

Since I feel like talking about coke today (“pop” or “soda” to you Yankees), I wondered if anyone else has noticed that Dr. Pepper quality varies widely at the various fast-food chains? While there may be weightier issues in this day and age, there are few that confront you with such frequency. I have, through the years, had the occasion to partake of the finest of all soft drinks at many establishments in many locations. And there is a strange consistency across most fast food places, regardless of the city or state.

The Rankings:

McDonald’s: while their burgers leave something to be desired, they have absolutely the best Dr. Pepper. Perfect fizziness, best balance of flavor. This is what God intended Dr. Pepper to taste like. And it’s rock-solid consistent no matter where you are.
Arby’s: A close second to McD’s, and sometimes indistinguishable, but I’ve found a bit more variability in Arby’s restaurants than in McD’s.
Whataburger: This is a new entrant in Mississippi, so I can only judge the two here plus the couple I’ve been to in Texas. Whataburger is really as good as Arby’s, but the small sample size means I can’t rank them as equal
Burger King: close to McD’s and Arby’s, but they need to work on the fizziness a little.
Pizza Hut: Often excellent, but they fall short enough that they take a hit on the consistency aspect
Taco Bell: almost a tie with BK, but sometimes it’s a little flat
Wendy’s: a bit too syrupy, but still reasonable good. Consistently inconsistent, though.
Popeye’s: almost pure syrup, and basically undrinkable. The only fast-food place where I refuse to order DP, and generally get water, because I figure they probably can’t get anything else right either

This came back to me when I ran across this article (“This Is Why Coke Tastes Better at McDonald’s Than Anywhere Else”) from a couple of years ago, explaining why cokes (and I assume by that they meant any carbonated beverage) really do taste better at McDonald’s. The explanation made sense, or would have ten years ago, but now? I’ve noticed a marked decline in the consistency of Dr. Pepper at McD’s, and despite what the article says it’s no longer true. Too often the taste is off, or it’s too syrupy (OTOH, their sweet tea is still excellent, just like I remember my grandmother making). So it’s time to revise my rankings:

Harry’s 2022 Dr. Pepper Rankings

  1. Whataburger
  2. Wendy’s – a major leap forward; only a bit of inconsistency keeps them from the #1 spot
  3. Arby’s
  4. Burger King
  5. Popeye’s – another vast improvement, at least based on the few times I’ve been the past couple of years
  6. McDonald’s – can still be excellent, like the old days, but so inconsistent now

Taco Bell has apparently dropped from their menu, so not only are they no longer in the rankings, they are restaurant non grata to me. And I haven’t eaten at a Pizza Hut in years, so I can’t include them.

Anyway, I just thought you’d like to know what I thought.

This entry was posted in Life. Bookmark the permalink.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *