I don’t pretend to be an expert in immigration issues. I don’t even claim to be all that knowledgeable about it. But it seems like the debate keeps coming down to a jobs thing – some people say illegal immigration (or even legal immigration) is taking away jobs from US citizens. Others say immigrants are mainly working jobs that US citizens didn’t want, either because of low pay or poor working conditions – number of hours, or the job environment – or because the job involves backbreaking physical labor. I have to admit that most immigrants I’ve seen here seem to be working in construction or on road crews. Certainly that’s an oversimplification, but those are two very visible job categories. However, it wouldn’t appear that they have taken jobs away from non-immigrants. Construction in my area has been booming for a while, and pretty much anyone who wants a job in the building trades can get one if they have any qualifications at all. And here’s where my probably too-simplistic thinking comes in. Rather than trying to make the US borders an armed encampment, why not simply pass a law that says priority in any job must go to a US citizen? If you’ve hired an immigrant, and a US citizen presents him- or herself as an applicant for that job, you must give them the job or create another equal job. And if immigrants getting welfare is a problem, then have a law that sets a very short time for benefits for non-citizens. I suspect what we’d see is that not many US citizens would show up to claim jobs from non-citizens, but if I’m wrong then we’d know how much of a problem it had been. Too simplistic, I know. But it makes as much sense as some proposals I’ve heard.
Blogs
- Bad Astronomy Blog
- Beyond The Fields We Know
- Crooked Timber
- Fruits and Votes
- In A Dark Time
- Kellogg Bloggin'
- Linkmeister
- Lost Pleiad Observatory
- Monkeymind
- Remodelaholic
- TalkLeft
- The Bemusement Park
- The Blog of Henry David Thoreau
- The Cassandra Pages
- The Philosophy of Nom
- The Solitary Walker
- The Superficial Cat
- The Urban Astronomer
- Traversing
- Treehugger
- Uncle Rod's Astro Blog
- What Does A Yellow Light Mean?
Poetry
Categories
Archives
Meta
I’ve heard the Hispanic work crews on the MS Coast are doing great work. While some local places are trying to retire on what they’re charging to hang a piece of sheetrock or put on a new roof, the immigrants are stepping in, doing great work, and charging much less. I’m sure the insurance industry is loving it.
I’ve heard that from others. I’ve also heard that the work they do on road crews is quite good.