Dissent In The Land Of The Free

Vice President Cheney has said that those calling for withdrawal of US troops from Iraq, or even publicly doubting the Administration’s “Stay the course” policy, are disloyal, and guilty of aiding the terrorists and betraying our soldiers. Opponents of the Administration policy respond by saying that leaving our soldiers in Iraq just continues making them targets for insurgent actions. Is either side right, or wrong, entirely? But when, and how, is public dissent proper? It would appear that Cheney and his supporters believe that once US soldiers are committed, dissent should stop. It seems to me, however, that such a practice would make it far too easy for a president to commit troops. In essence, once hostilities had begun, the nation would be locked in. So, we presume the right of dissent, at least in some circumstances. During the Vietnam War, some dissent took the form of direct action against government installations, such as the 1970 armory bombing in Santa Barbara, CA. I think most of those opposed to the Iraq war would agree that antiwar violence is inappropriate. But if a senator speaking out against the war is aiding terrorists, is that also true of a citizen writing a letter opposing the war to that senator? Is a letter to the editor of the local paper an act of disloyalty? In a democracy, in a government of, by, and for the people, is it not the role of a citizen dissatisfied with the policy and actions of the government to signify that dissatisfaction? On the other hand, many of those who oppose the war insist that they support the troops. That’s a sentiment that’s expressed so often that it runs the danger of becoming nothing more than a platitude. So, if public dissent is proper, when is it proper, and where? I think it’s important to remember that the policies behind the war are political, which means the arena of dissent should be political. If you’re going to claim you support the soldiers, that means no protests at military installations, or occasions that honor troops or veterans. At least, if I were in charge of the rules, that’s what they’d be. You’re not protesting the war, you’re protesting the politicians who committed us to the war. That’s where dissent should be aimed. But that’s a fine line to walk, especially when your opponents are charging you with disloyalty or even treason. Could it be that those are the people who are being “un-American” – those who would stifle any protest by hiding behind a Nixonian brand of patriotism that divides the world into only unquestioning supporters and enemies? While that may be sufficient in a dictatorship, it’s poison to a democracy, just as dissent that includes personal attacks, that denigrates those who hold different opinions and ideas, is also poison to a democracy. Dissent that relies on cheap stunts – and I’m thinking of Cindy Sheehan and other activists “dying” in front of the White House – is only slightly less poisonous. To be effective, dissent must be honest, respectful, and thoughtful. Anything less is just angry men, and women, shouting.

This entry was posted in Politics. Bookmark the permalink.

2 Responses to Dissent In The Land Of The Free

  1. Karen says:

    I am married to a Vietnam vet who is so furious with the conduct of the anti-war left that he is calling for the Sedition Act of 1918 to be put back into effect. You make some valid points on both sides of the argument. My husband also traveled to Iraq for business just before the war began and he is adamant that the Iraqi people deserve nothing less than freedom. It won’t look like our democracy there, but it will be their democracy. In January he hosted 2 Iraqi engineers while teaching some classes and they were very specific in saying that they are grateful for the opportunities available to them and their families now. Some areas of the country have major problems still today but much of the country is functioning much better and life is continuing without the restraints of a ruthless dictator. I could go on and on. I will say this – those that don’t support the mission are not supporting the troops. To say otherwise is extremely dishonest. There will always be a certain proportion of our population that is disdainful of our military. Isolationism at its worst.

  2. scott says:

    To steal the tagline from another site, this post is “A drop of reason in a pool of confusion.” Excellent.

Comments are closed.