Not surprisingly, the blogosphere and the media are full of opinions and advice for the Democratic Party in the wake of the election. And yes, this is another of those. But while I thought, on Wednesday morning, that the election was a disaster for the Democrats, I’m not so pessimistic after thinking about it for a few days. I do think, however, that it can still turn into a disaster. How? By having bitter and disappointed Democrats turn this into a genuine “us versus them” scenario. By engaging in conspiracy theory mantras about rigged voting machines and lockdowns and voting irregularities. By acting like the spoiled, arrogant elitists that many conservatives (and moderates) believe they are. By overreacting to some things and underreacting to others. There are real issues, and there are perceptions, and there are false assumptions with which the Democrats must deal. Let’s start with the false assumptions.
False Assumption 1: George Bush won because millions of ignorant right-wing Christian Moral Majority Bible-thumper types turned off their brains and voted based on their hypocritical intolerant “morality issues”. The “culture gap” is real, even if it’s only a perceived gap. There are issues that bother conservatives and evangelical Christians greatly. Chief among these are abortion and gay marriage. And on these two issues, but especially on abortion, neither side will be able to change the other’s mind. And the reason for this is, neither side can prove their “truth” without relying on either religious faith or, for lack of a better term, humanistic logic. For instance, on abortion, there simply is no way to prove that a fertilized egg is a soul-endowed human being. That doesn’t mean it may not be true, but absent the religious imperatives that drive the anti-abortion Christian (or other religious) community, the “proof” doesn’t exist. So any movement on this issue will require a degree of compromise by both sides. And compromise requires a degree of respect and tolerance on both sides. The steady mantra of anti-Christian diatribes coming from many in the militant Left doesn’t do anything to help this. In fact, it plays right into the claims of conservative leaders that there is a morality gap, and that Christians really are under attack. Supporters of abortion rights and gay rights have to understand that the people who opposed Kerry because, at least partially, of these two issues have legitimate issues, based on deeply-held religious and moral beliefs. That doesn’t mean they are right on these issues, but their right to hold the positions is legitimate. These are not bad people. They are not stupid people. And if the “Christer-bashing” continues, many Christian liberals and moderates are going to feel like the Democratic Party has no place for them. And the next election will be a true disaster for liberals.
False Assumption 2: The election was once again rigged by the Bushies. Just drop it. We’re coming off as whiny, bitter losers who can’t deal with reality. Sure, there were some flaky things, but we got outvoted by 3 million votes. It’s time to think about the next election, not the last one.
False Assumption 3: The Democrats can win without the South. Sure, you can work the mathematics to make this seem realistic. But if you write off 20% of the states, you have to have everything fall your way every time. And pilosophically, if you’re not at least trying to compete in all parts of the nation, you’re not a national party, and you don’t deserve to be. The Democrats will have to change their platform and their message to appeal to Southern voters, but that’s a fact of political life. The world happens. If Democrats want to be the modern Whigs, so be it. But if they really want to ever win the Presidency again, or control either house of Congress, they have to have some wins in the South.
Now the perceptions:
Perception 1: Democrats don’t go to church. This is incorrect, of course, but not totally off-base. There was a time when liberal politics was led by committed Christians, trying to right the wrongs of society. Civil rights, poverty, human rights, hunger, all were pushed by church-going Democrats. But gradually, liberal Christians began to let their voices be stilled. Now they seem to be embarrassed to admit that the teachings of Jesus have a place in their political philosophy. If the “us versus them” I noted above isn’t going to become a yawning, unbridgable chasm, these liberal Christians have to become vocal once more, and their message has to be rooted in recognizable Christian theology. I’m not calling for the Democrats to become a left-wing mirror of the Republican right-wing theocracy; I’m just saying, if the Democrats are going to be able to counter the charges of the right wingers, there has to be a Christian voice in the Party.
Perception 2: Democrats are weak on military and defense issues. It’s ridiculous to charge people who have voted for hundreds of billions of dollars in defense spending with being weak on defense. So learn to talk about military issues with credibility. And make it clear that Democrats are willing to take names and kick butt when it’s called for. Adopt TR’s philosophy – walk softly and carry a big stick.
Perception 3: Democrats are tax-and-spend liberals. One thing the past 25 years have shown is that even if Democrats aren’t reducing the size of government, they’re more fiscally responsible than Republicans. But it can’t always be about tax increases. Learn to propose real, serious, tangible cuts in programs that are bloated. Let the Republicans establish a track record of refusing to cut even while the deficits grow. And learn to defend reasonable, effective government spending.
And now the real issues:
Real Issue 1: Campaigning. John Kerry ran a terrible campaign, beset by bickering, indecision, and just plain inneffective management. Al Gore’s 2000 campaign was terribly mismanaged. Meanwhile, the Republicans are fielding battle-tough, no-nonsense, take-no-prisoners campaign teams focused on one thing – winning. Democrats, by comparison, look like rank amateurs. Other than James Carville, I can’t think of a Democratic strategist who seems to understand how to play this game. Politics is a dirty, nasty business. It’s hand-to-hand combat. While we’re in the wilderness, let’s develop some campaigners.
Real Issue 2: This relates to False Assumption 1 – the Democratic Party has to decide whether it’s a party dedicated to competing and winning political campaigns at the national and congressional level, or whether it’s just a collection of advocacy groups willing to settle for getting their issues discussed on the national stage. If it’s the former, then they have to develop a set of core issues and values that define them, and that resonate with the American voting public. This may well mean telling some of their constituent groups that their laundry list of issues won’t make it into the platform. “If you defend everything, you defend nothing”.
Real Issue 3: There are issues that matter, and are, or should be, Democratic strengths. Health care, the environment, energy, infrastructure, even education to an extent – these are below the radar of the public at the moment, but they’ll resurface, and Democrats need to have maintained or re-established their credibility there, and need to be ready to use these to batter their way back into power. These are the places they can fight over the next four years, and they can do it in a way that raises their legitimacy.
Real Issue 4: Restructure the primary season. It used to be that primaries and caucuses began in late January or early February, and were spread across the next 4 months. Candidates would get noticed in Iowa and New Hampshire, and then tested over a mini-marathon ending in California. There was time to take the measure of the person, to see them in a variety of settings and political environs. Now we make our decisions about a nominee in a matter of weeks, so that only a handful of states has a say; and more important, a candidate has to only sustain momentum for a few weeks. I’m convinced John Edwards would not have been a serious contender if he’d had to keep his campaign going for four months. He had immediate appeal, but not lasting appeal. And his near-disappearance in the general election campaign bears this out. We don’t need to be in such a rush to get the nomination settled.
Anyway, that’s what I think. I’m disappointed that Kerry lost, but I’m already tired of the weeping, wailing, and gnashing of teeth. The Republicans won, they’ll have their way with the political scene for a while. It won’t last, unless Democrats let it last by forfeiting the game.
The conservafundy thinks you wrote a good blog here. One big reason Kerry lost is the the same big reason Bob Dole lost in ’96. Running a campaign as the Anti-Incumbent rarely works. The liberal Democrat movement makes a lot of good points, but they often fail to organize it into an effective campaign. Moreover, they’re often so concerned with including everyone that they abandon their sense of focus. As an old boss once told me, “When you’re all things to all people, you’re nothing to yourself.”
Good blog!
Wow! Great post and Great blog! How have I missed this before? Thanks for popping over to my site so that I could find yours. I’ll be back….
“neither side can prove their “truth” without relying on either religious faith or, for lack of a better term, humanistic logic. For instance, on abortion, there simply is no way to prove that a fertilized egg is a soul-endowed human being”
That depends on what will be accepted as “proof”. Is there a verse that says “It’s a person at conception. Thus sayeth the Lord.”? No. But I still say that the massive weight of evidence (which is how most decisions in life are made anyway) in Scripture, biology, and logic point to personhood at conception. Very few of our decisions flow from absolute information, yet we make life and death choices every day. I’ll have a post up on this soon, the first of my “platform” posts.
BTW, the previous posters are right. You have stepped your blog up a notch since moving to a new domain name. The rest of us losers should do as well. 🙂
The Republicans won a bunch of elections from 1880-1928 without ever carrying a bit of the South, and the country was much smaller then. So I think your thinking on that point is a bit suspect.
If you’re having to reach back to William Jennings Bryan to make your case, you’re pretty much proving my point.
I think Democrats need to rethink their strategies. The best way to achieve victory is from the grassroots up, not the top down. The Republican grass roots effort started in 1964 with Barry Goldwater. 16 years later, Ronald Reagan won the Presidency and started implementing the Goldwater vision.
There was also a second Republican Revolution that until now has gone unnoticed. It was conceived in Jerry Falwell’s moral majority, which supported Reagan. But ideologically, Reagan’s governing philosophy was not dependent upon Falwell. It was a loose association.
The real birth of the second Republican renewal started with Pat Robertson’s run for office in 1988, and the founding of the Christian Coalition with Ralph Reed as its head. Just as Goldwater was ill-suited to give practical political legs to his vision, Robertson was ill-suited to be the embodiment of his vision as well. But like “young” Ronald Reagan, young Ralph Reed focused on the development of a political organization to implement the vision.
Karl Rove is not a genius. He was and is simply smart enough to tap into the political organization developed by Reed. George W. Bush is the beneficiary of that movement that also started 16 years before its full impact on national politics was felt.
A word about the divisions within the Republican party. The Republican party is divided into four factions.
1) The old Taft Republicans. These are the old Northeastern WASP Republicans. George H.W. Bush was the embodiment of this group, as is Arlen Specter – the pro-business GOP. This group greatly misunderstands and even resents Group 4 Moral Values Republicans and are most vulnerable to being picked off by another ideological movement.
2) The limited government Republicans. Both Ronald Reagan and Newt Gingrich represented this group. These are also the term-limits Republicans who honored their pledges to serve only six years in the Legislature. These guys HATE, HATE, HATE the deficits and the debt. They love tax-cuts and slashing government programs. If you are against deficits, these guys will jump in bed with you at the drop of a hat.
3) National Security Republicans. This group is the result of a backlash against the anti-war movements of the 60’s and early 70’s, and also newly minted anti-terrorists hawks. Many of these people are the “Reagan Democrats” and “9/11 Democrats.” Think Zell Miller, Ed Koch, Sam Nunn, Rudi Giuliani etc. Also, think of libertarian bloggers like Glenn Reynolds, and Roger L. Simon, and Dean Esmay.
4) The Moral Values Republicans. These are the quintessential Republican “little people.” They/We are animated by fighting judicial tyranny. We resent our values being trampled upon by both the unelected whims of federal judges, and by the propaganda of Hollywood and the Press. This group is naturally isolationist and not particularly interested in the day-to-day practical aspect of governing. We are determined to have the Supreme Court retrofitted to immunize the Society from cases like the Massachusetts Supreme Court’s attempt to impose gay marriage on the nation.
Contrary to most liberals’ fears, we would be content to let issues like gay marriage, abortion, etc be resolved in the legislature. What this group has in common with liberals is a high value for individual freedom. What liberals don’t understand is that freedom for us includes the freedom from having liberal sensibilities imposed on us from outside. Having had our values trampled onby the judiciary since 1962, we are not animated by the prospect of reversing that imposition, i.e. the fear of liberals of the religious right imposing our values on them is unfounded.
What is important is permanently changing the structure of government to prohibit judges from making up the law without popular consent. Education reform is also very high on the agenda of Moral Values Republicans. Tax policy, the size of government, and pro-business policies are secondary to this group, and liberal economic policies are easily tolerated and even sometimes championed by members of this group.
This group is also your natural “FREE SPEECH” ally, if you consider political correctness of universities and campaign finance reform to be wrong. But remember, “FREE SPEECH” to these people also means the right to erect nativity scenes on public property.
Confusing the members of the four Republican factions with one another is endemic in liberal circles. Republicans may be members of more than one group, and sometimes resent being called out for the primary agendas of other Republican groups which they do not agree with. Consider how some moral values Republicans like Pat Robertson are adamantly opposed to the War in Iraq, and old-style GOP Senator Arlen Specter warning the White House not to nominate anti-Roe judges.
So what lessons should Democrats take from these two consecutive conservative movements?
1) You must stand FOR something, not just against something. For 32 years prior to Goldwater, the Republican party was in the wilderness. Ike was the Clinton of the Republican party, i.e. he made them feel good for 8 years, but offered no real ideological raison d’etre for the Republican party. The Taft Republicans were primarily animated by trying to undue the work of FDR – something that they ultimately were never able to accomplish, even to today.
2) Ideas matter greatly. You must first establish your fundamental core beliefs and stick to them regardless of whether those ideas are quickly accepted by the populace. One of the great lines in GWB’s acceptance speech at the RNC was “you know where I stand.” It was true. Even GWB’s most ardent opponents knew where he stood. Even now, I am confused about what Kerry’s governing philosophy would be. The one clear ideological concept that I was able to discern was internationalism – something I regard as secondary, i.e. Internationalism for its own sake seems vaccuous to me, elevating process over substance.
3) It takes time. The American electorate is tired of those on the left trying to use the courts to circumvent the electoral process. Trust me when I say that the success of the gay marriage bans in 11 states was more about limiting the power of the runaway judiciary than it was about homophobia or gay-bashing. You want gay marriage? Fine. Do the hard work of convincing the American population that it is a worthwhile evolution in our society. Trying to cram it down the throats of social conservatives by judicial fiat is a recipe for division.
Both of the conservative ideological movements took 16 years to reach maturity in Presidential politics, and the Goldwater movement took 30 years to reach maturity in the Legislature. A true Progressive ideological movement is likely to require the same maturation process.
4) Renewal. Every philosophy needs ideological renewal. The conservative ideological renewal is well into its second phase. There was 24 years between the birth of its first ideology and its second ideology. The Liberals had a similar time lag in their 20th century ideological successes – first the New Deal, then the Great Society. But since then, there has not been any great ideological liberal movement. Liberalism has become reactionary, defending the gains of movements that are 70 years old and 40 years old respectively.
Conclusion: Unless liberals are content to spend the next several decades in the political wasteland of American politics, like the early 20th century Republicans, an ideological renewal is necessary. Also necessary is patience, perserverance and a willingness to do the hard work of gaining grass roots popular support for your causes.
The whine of “divided America” sounds like sour grapes to conservatives. And any expectation that conservatives will not press ahead with an agenda and movement that we have been building for now 40 years is extremely naive. For too many years, we were in the minority. And for too many years our issues were ignored, passed over, and dismissed. Having worked so hard for so long, we intend to have our satisfaction.
The onus is on liberals to create and build their own alternative movement(s). Certainly, liberals have some things in common with all of the identified factions of the Republican party described above, and with hard work and persistence could find issues which would enable you to peel off voters from the above voting block. Good luck.