Estate taxes

Left Oblique and Jammerblog have both commented on the philosophy of estate taxes. And I’ve come to realize that my problem with eliminating estate taxes really comes down to untaxed capital gains. Money in a bank account has been taxed at some point. Dividends paid have been taxed. But a stock that was bought and never sold has accumulated capital gains that, if passed on, will simply go untaxed forever, I guess. If the inheriting person later sells that stock, how are the gains calculated? From the value at the time of inheritance? In that case, value gained before that time simply escapes taxation. But it wouldn’t seem fair for the heir to pay taxes that the original owner would have owed. The only logical thing to do, it would seem, is to tax the estate for capital gains accumulated at the time of the owner’s death.

Meanwhile, here’s a quote. 5 points if you tell me who said it:

“By taxing estates heavily at death the state marks it’s condemnation of he selfish millionaire’s unworthy life.”

This entry was posted in Politics. Bookmark the permalink.

One Response to Estate taxes

  1. Dave says:

    Rush? O’Reilly? Coulter? Scarborough? The language is the typical late-20th/early-21st Century Republican class-warfare-speak.

    I have a real problem with political rhetoric that attributes or assumes motive by the other side. It’s the same as the “liberals believe X because they hate America” meme – though I’ve seen it used just as effectively by the Left under different circumstances.

    Attributing false motive is a subtle variation on the “poisoning the well” fallacy. This is when an argument is discredited not by a counter-argument, but rather by painting the argument’s supporter(s) in an unfavorable light. Estate taxes, by this sort of argument, are bad not on some economic or philosophical grounds, but rather because the people who favor them allegedly hate and envy the rich. (Even if this were true, of course, it still doesn’t prove that estate taxes are bad.)

Comments are closed.