What’s so special about Iowa?

That’s a question I keep hearing. There are lots of explanations around, but I’ll take a stab at explaining it. The Three Rules Of Real Estate are Location, Location, Location. It’s pretty much the same way with Iowa. The Three Keys To Understanding Iowa are First, First, First. After a year or more of positioning, performing, pretending, and proposing, the Iowa caucuses are finally an actual, countable vote (of sorts). After months and months of polls, Iowa is the real thing; at least, it’s the most real thing until the next real thing, the New Hampshire primary, which is a bit more of a Real Thing because more people participate.


But it’s still two small states. And two states that aren’t particularly representative of the country at large. Iowa does a little better on this point – arguably, a Midwestern state is more representative than a New England state. But it’s a debatable point. So, what’s so special about Iowa? The winner of the Iowa caucuses isn’t always the nominee. In fact, they often aren’t. In 1980, George Bush won Iowa. In 1988, Richard Gephardt won the Democratic vote, while Bob Dole won the Republican side. In 1992, native son Tom Harkin won the Democratic caucus, but his being an Iowa senator kept most other candidates out of the state, so he won by default.

On the other hand, Iowa has often givena boost to candidates who didn’t finish first. In 1972, George McGovern finished third, but a close third behind favorite Ed Muskie of Maine and the uncommitted vote. That finish boosted him in the media spotlight and helped him defeat Muskie for the nomination. In 1984, Gary Hart surprised everyone except himself by finishing second; a week later, he won the New Hampshire primary. Had the Democratic selection process not been geared to help Mondale specifically, Hart would very likely have ridden those successes to the nomination.

So, what’s so special about Iowa? I think, mainly, it’s the flip side. Candidates who unexpectedly do poorly in Iowa are generally finished. George Bush in 1988 is the exception, but Iowa nearly finished him. The field of candidates usually shrinks a little after Iowa, and barring remarkable comebacks, those who do poorly in Iowa don’t last long afterwards. So think of Iowa as a sort of personnel department, doing those first-line job interviews so only legitimate candidates are presented for the later, serious interviews. Somebody’s got to winnow the field, and cold, windy Iowa in January every four years steps up and does the job.

This entry was posted in Politics. Bookmark the permalink.