The Weather Channel Meterologist Controversy

Lots of chatter about this. I decided to see what actually was said. Dr. Heidi Cullen was reacting to a blog interview with a DC-area TV meteorologist, Brian van de Graaf, who had this to say about global warming:

“The subject of global warming definitely makes headlines in the media and is a topic of much debate. I try to read up on the subject to have a better understanding, but it is complex. Often, it is so politicized and those on both sides don’t always appear to have their facts straight. History has taught us that weather patterns are cyclical and although we have noticed a warming pattern in recent time, I don’t know what generalizations came be made from this with the lack of long-term scientific data. That’s all I will say about this.”

Dr. Cullen then noted a later entry on that same blog (Capitalweather.com) which responded to van de Graaf’s statement:

“”If that were a question on a climate science exam, van de Graaf better hope for partial credit. Sure, there are cyclical patterns of climate change and weather patterns, but he misses the more important point about trends in long-term data.

The global surface thermometer record only stretches back to the 1800s, but reliable traces of the planet’s temperature can be made stretching back thousands of years using ice cores, tree ring records, ocean sediments and other “proxy” methods. Together, these records have showed a stark warming trend during the past century, particularly the last 30 years, that is out of step with previous shifts.

Scientists have identified human emissions of greenhouse gases, such as carbon dioxide, as the most likely culprit for the warming. This is the opinion of most climate scientists, and van de Graaf and others should know this and communicate this to the public….

Van de Graaf and his colleagues can look to the American Meteorological Society, which awards them their television “seals of approval” and hence their legitimacy as TV meteorologists, for a nonpartisan scientific view on climate change.

More than three years ago the AMS issued a statement on climate change that said: “There is convincing evidence that since the industrial revolution, human activities, resulting in increasing concentrations of greenhouse gases and other trace constituents in the atmosphere, have become a major agent of climate change.”

Perhaps AMS members should be required to read the organization’s statements and consider getting on board with the group’s new emphasis on becoming station scientists. Either that, or continue to be left out of covering the biggest weather story of all time.”

Dr. Cullen referred to that blog post, and went on to say:

“”I’d like to take that suggestion a step further. If a meteorologist has an AMS Seal of Approval, which is used to confer legitimacy to TV meteorologists, then meteorologists have a responsibility to truly educate themselves on the science of global warming… Meteorologists are among the few people trained in the sciences who are permitted regular access to our living rooms. And in that sense, they owe it to their audience to distinguish between solid, peer-reviewed science and junk political controversy. If a meteorologist can’t speak to the fundamental science of climate change, then maybe the AMS shouldn’t give them a Seal of Approval”.

So – not quite as extreme a statement as this Alabama broadcast meteorologist would have you believe. Also – Spann makes the statement that “Billions of dollars of grant money is flowing into the pockets of those on the man-made global warming bandwagon”. I can’t find anything close to that. The Federal government spent a few hundred million dollars on climate research in 2005, the latest year for which I could find figures. Here’s the link for that. That amount will buy you a few days of war in Iraq, by the way. I doubt that private sources are covering the remaining billions Spann claims. On the other hand, ExxonMobil is spending millions to convince people that the science behind global warming isn’t legitimate. I don’t claim to know for sure whether we’re causing some of the problem. With all the data that’s accumulating indicating we are, I’m inclined to believe that there’s some fire under all that smoke, and if we can put some of it out, we should.

Dr. Cullen’s original blog post is here, followed by this post.

Posted in Environment | 5 Comments

Spam Block Spam

I tried to send an email to someone tonight, someone I know but wouldn’t consider a close friend. I got this back:

I apologize for this automatic reply to your email.

To control spam, I now allow incoming messages only from senders I have approved beforehand.

If you would like to be added to my list of approved senders, please fill out the short request form (see link below). Once I approve you, I will receive your original message in my inbox. You do not need to resend your message. I apologize for this one-time inconvenience.

Click the link below to fill out the request:

Needless to say, I didn’t fill out the short request form, and therefore won’t be approved. And therefore, he won’t receive my email. I don’t know many people who use those spam-blockers,fortunately, because I really don’t like the implication that somehow I’m not worthy to send emails. What really bothers me is when people on mailing lists turn these things on – as a listowner, when I encounter someone doing this, I block them from the list. I hate spam as much as the next person, but this isn’t the way to handle it.

Changing the subject, I think the President is giving a pretty good speech tonight. A much different tone than his previous speeches. I’d give him a B+. Not that I agree with everything he said, but it was a good speech nonetheless.

Interesting – on the way out, the President walked right past Senator Lott. Shook hands before and after him, but not Trent’s.

Posted in Geek Stuff | 2 Comments

Over The Rainbow

Just because I like the song, and these versions…

Posted in Music | Comments Off on Over The Rainbow

It’s What All The Cool Ostriches Are Doing

“there are things we know we know. We also know there are known unknowns; that is to say we know there are some things we do not know. But there are also unknown unknowns — the ones we don’t know we don’t know.”

Donald Rumsfeld said lots of things during his time before an open mic, but this has always been one of my favorites. It’s also one of the things he said that actually made perfect sense to me. But in the global warming debate, it probably should be re-written:

“there are things we know we know. We also know there are known unknowns; that is to say we know there are some things we do not know. But there are also unknown unknowns — and we don’t have to worry about those.”

I’m not going to say that human activities are definitely causing an abnormal change in natural warming and cooling cycles. There is plenty of evidence that something is happening – carbon dioxide levels seem to be higher than at any point in the past hundred thousand years, and the rate of increase seems to be increasing abnormally; permafrost that has been frozen for over ten thousand years is melting (which could release methane, a more destructive greenhoue gas than carbon dioxide, into the atmosphere); the Greenland ice sheet appears to be melting faster than natural cycling would predict. You can find more examples – but none provide absolute evidence of global warming caused by human activity, and apparently it will require absolute evidence before some people will decide we should try to do something. I overheard a conversation the other day, some people talking about Al Gore’s movie “An Inconvenient Truth”. One of the people replied “I’m a Republican, I don’t listen to Al Gore”. That makes as much sense as someone who says “I don’t like that doctor, so I’m not getting my child vaccinated”. Their child might not get sick anyway, so why worry? But we do worry, and even though nothing may happen, we do something about it. We do something because we can. The history of vaccine development shows it was expensive, it was often controversial, and during the process many very smart people got some things wrong. But we were smart enough to understand that something was going on that we could affect. Looking back over the past century, it seems like a pretty damn good idea. If we’re driving and we see something that causes us to be uncertain of the road conditions ahead, we slow down until we’re sure. We don’t just go speeding on. Unless, of course, we’re idiots. We recognize that we need more data, and until we get more data we should proceed with a little caution.

So what’s the deal with the global warming debate? Maybe we don’t have everything right. Maybe we don’t understand all the data. But we have the technology to do some things. We could clean things up a bit while we’re trying to understand better what’s happening. But it’s so much easier to just sit there and do nothing, and point to every pseudo-scientific or near-scientific study claiming to refute the studies that show something we don’t want to believe. It’s easier to say “we’re not sure, let’s not do anything right now”, and find the one or two guys in the room saying things we agree with.

As a friend said this weekend, it’s what all the cool ostriches are doing this year.

Posted in Environment | 3 Comments

Sliced And Diced By Occam’s Razor

I got an email from one of our users yesterday – unable to connect to their test database. I have a small universe of test databases. There’s the near-clone of the current production database, the near-clone of the previous version of the production database which was upgraded to the current version as a final test of the upgrade procedures; there’s the database being used to test the new module supporting the National Emissions Inventory, and a clone of that database being used for performance testing. There’s the database being used to test the next version of the application, and the database being used for Oracle10g verification and SQL/XML development. I finally managed to kill off two databases that were being used by two different groups doing separate draft permit development. And those are just the test databases for our primary application. Then there’s the primary production database itself, and three databases supporting other applications, and two test databases for those. It’s not like we’re not that big a place! I need a database of passwords for all the different databases.

So, I received an email from one of the users of one of these test databases. They’re in an office in another part of town, and they couldn’t connect to the particular test database they wanted to hit. I had them try a couple of things, with no success, so after lunch today I went to that office. Start the application, “cannot resolve service name”. Check the database ID, its OK. Ping the server, OK fine. Tnsping the database, it’s OK. Try the app again, make sure I saw the error correctly, yes, I did. Change the database ID to a different database on the same server. OK fine. Change back, nada. Telnet to the server, stop the listener, restart the listener. Try the app again. Annnkkkk! Check the tnsnames file. It’s good. Fire up SQL*Plus, try to connect to the target database. Nothing. Try to connect to another database on that server. OK fine. Fire up the Oracle net config utility. Test the connection. Can’t test it, I’m using a redirect in the tnsnames file. Rats! Fire up the app again, because I can’t think of what the problem might be, stall for time while I think. Still won’t connect. Not surprised. Check the connection info again, compare the port numbers. OK fine. At this point I’m pretty baffled. I telnet to the server again, decide to connect to the database directly.

The database was down. The database was down. I’d shut it down a week or so ago when I was setting up another database on that server, and hadn’t brought it back online. I spent an hour trying all sorts of remedies to various connectivity hypotheses, and the problem was the thing I should have checked first, the most obvious and therefore the simplest solution. The database was down. Occam’s Razor. Numquam ponenda est pluralitas sine necessitate. You should never focus on the solutions to a problem before you’ve focused on the problem itself. Forests and trees.

Numquam ponenda est pluralitas sine necessitate. Indeed.

Posted in Geek Stuff | 1 Comment