Today is Holy Saturday, a term I first heard today. The day between Good Friday and Easter Sunday. Mark at The Bemusement Park calls it one of the strangest days of the year (for context, Mark is a Lutheran pastor):
Then it all fades into what for me is one of the strangest days of the year: Holy Saturday. If the Christian imagination can’t capture a proper sense of Good Friday — and it can’t, because how do you forget Easter is coming? — then Holy Saturday is a lost cause. Holy Saturday might as well be called The Rockin’ Easter Pre-Party, Presented by White Claw Seltzer.
And that’s a shame. A crying shame. We miss a golden opportunity to reflect on what our world might have been like. What if Jesus wasn’t raised from the dead? What if his death didn’t take away the sins of the world? What if there’s a dessicated pile of bones out there somewhere in an ossuary with the wrong name on it? What if he wasn’t the Son of God? What if Mary made the whole thing up? Or the disciples?
I’m aware, believe me, that many people assert all the above, and more. I wonder, though, why more Christians never ponder the possibilities. Maybe it’s a little too close to touching the third rail, I don’t know, but to me they’re interesting questions. I think an examined faith is a lot better than an unexamined one.
And this evening, I read a post at Traversing, another of those rare blogs that still updates. Andrew wrote Resurrection for Non-Christians: A Poem:
Stay with me now, you non-Christians (of which I am one).
The hard believers will insist there’s nothing for you here,
Irredeemable heathens that you persist in Being.
But believe not, I say, in those believers, their binaries
Blinding them to nuance, context, symbol, the
Dusky liminal depths of myth more real than reality.Resurrection is yours, too, for the taking.
You need not wear a cross on your chest,
Nor hang on one for the many sins you
Share in common with your brothers and sisters,
Perfection being the chimera that the
Christ himself was said to dispel.Sinning is yours, too, for the committing…
I live in a world of doubt, and questions, and uncertainty. It wasn’t always this way. I grew up, if I did ever grow up, and still live in Mississippi, the heart of the Bible Belt. I attended church, and still do except for the interruption that COVID has brought, in Methodist churches, Southern Baptist churches, back to the United Methodist church. During my earlier years it was a time and place where it was assumed that you either went to church regularly, got salvation, listened to the preacher, and believed, else you were a hardened atheist. Doubt was not a thing you did, and certainly not something you mentioned in religious company. Somewhere along the winding path my life has taken, somewhere in the midst of the people I’ve been, keeping doubt away got harder. I don’t doubt the existence of God, but sometimes I have trouble believing He takes daily interest, especially in trivial things. Given my willingness to accept the existence of God, I can make space for the occasional miracle – I mean, if God is God then he can spin those out if He (or She!) wants to. But sometimes I wonder, had I been born in New Hampshire, or Minnesota, or England, or Norway, would the Christianity I still claim be the same. Would I be troubled by some of the questions that seem to dance in and out of my mind? Am I troubled by a theological Christianity or a societal Christianity? But these are the very sorts of questions that I can’t bring up in polite church company here. Doubt is tantamount to unbelief, and unbelief is what sends you to the utter darkness. Here, anyway.
Maybe, as Mark wrote, Holy Saturday is a natural time to doubt. One day out of the year, I’m afraid, isn’t enough for me, but for now I’ll run with it. And for any wayward soul who happens to pass by this tiny speck among the ghost towns of the internet, Happy Easter.


