Crashing The Parties

Jammerblog is talking about needing a fifth political party in the US. I agree, except that we need a viable third party first. The Libertarians have some interesting ideas, but I don’t see their overall platform as being workable in the USA of today. Perhaps that’s stated a bit strong, but doing away with all public schools, ending all drug laws, eliminating all foreign aid, and reducing the defense budget by 70% aren’t realistic. The Green Party, with which I share many ideals, did itself immense harm by choosing to make a big play in the 2000 election. In doing so, it confined itself to a minor fringe of the most liberal segment of out political landscape.


What is needed is a revival of the old liberal wing of the Republican party, combined with Democrats who have long been uncomfortable with what some see as pandering to left-wing constituencies. A party of people who hold progressive-to-liberal views on issues such as the environment, baseline social services, and economic development, who tend to favor a strong military, but perhaps aren’t willing to buy into “typical” liberal positions on “morality issues”. Neither party is likely, in the near future, to embrace these groups within their existing party structures.

But more than just giving a home to a group that now feels somewhat disenfranchised, the presence of a major third party would force a fundamental shift in the governmental status quo. What we’ve seen over the past 20-25 years tends to be an almost unthinking blind reaction to what the other side has done. Compromise has been increasingly rare. Action/reaction has become the political order of the day. But what if there were suddenly a third player? Action/reaction doesn’t function so well when there is an escape from potential deadlock. Those less committed on a particular issue have an alternative to stubborn resistance or caving. Certainly, it wouldn’t always work smoothly. Three-way logjams are always possible. But after 200+ years of mostly two-party governance, maybe it’s time to amend our thinking.

This entry was posted in Politics. Bookmark the permalink.

4 Responses to Crashing The Parties

  1. Brian S says:

    I’m not so sure about the need of a third party.

    The two party system tends to force compromise without the ‘fringe’ getting some huge say in what the final outcome is. If you have some huge ‘tie’ on something between the two majors and some small fringe party can throw their weight behind some bill to get it passed but they want ‘all logging stopped in Oregon’ they can get a HUGE push for what they want by basicaly forming a coalition with the party willing to cave to them. This is what happens in a lot of parlimentary type governments.

    No, I don’t really want a viable third party. What I DO WANT is a viable TWO party structure. The Republicans are leaning way to far, I wouldn’t even call it right, but into big buisness greed. While the Democrats are leaning way too far left for me. If one or the other would reform itself or simply implode and create your third party but really become the new second party, while what is left of the old party becomes fringe, I would be a supporter of that new party pretty fast.

    I tend to be a centrist on many issues and quite franky have very little strong feelings on a lot of others. The party that moves towards the center first gets people like me and my vote.

    Frankly, I think both partys would do well to do some major reform and kick out their fringe which seems to be at the reigns right now.

  2. scott says:

    I like your design for the new party, Harry, with the qualification that ‘baseline social services’ should be just that, baseline. (You may have meant that) Most social services should be done at the neighboorhood level, in my opinion.

  3. Dave says:

    Third parties can only get seats in parliamentary systems where there is proportional representation. In a winner-take-all system like ours, splitting votes between parties with similar platforms hurts both parties (see the ’92 and ’00 elections for examples).

    Having two dominant parties is pretty much a feature of our political system. A new party can force an older party out, but three can’t coexist – it’s an unstable configuration.

  4. I guess the first and third commenters have it right; I wasn’t talking about a true permanent third party so much as a party that would come along and pick up the sensible parts of the two existing parties, and do unto one of them what the Republicans did to the Whigs.

Comments are closed.