Will The Fortress Hold?

With less than three weeks to go before the November mid-term elections, people allover the blogosphere and across the country are peering intently at the political landscape and trying to make sense of it. Throughout, polls are showing Democrats either enjoying unexpectedly large leads, or running neck-and-neck in races that six months ago were thought to be safely Republican. President Bush’s approval ratings have been in the 30s for weeks, with only a slight bump immediately following the 9/11 remembrances to temporarily break the grim numbers. Congress, controlled by the Republicans, has hit an all-time low in approval. The war, having gone from bad to worse, seems to be going to Stygian depths. Corruption and immorality seems to be rampant among Republican elected officials. And Democrats have recruited a bumper crop of fresh new candidates, with funding to go along with them. The stage would seem to be set for a political upheaving of colossal proportions. And it may happen, notes Michael Stickings at The Moderate Voice. Or it may be nothing more than a mighty wind. Because in the midst of their gloom, Republicans still have some things going for them. In the House of Representatives, a decade of redictricting has provided them with a large number of seats like Mississippi’s Third Congressional District, where Chip Pickering would just about have to be caught in bed with a dead girl or a live boy to be defeated. I would say “live man”, but there’s precedent here for a Republican surviving that occurrence, at least the first time. You’ve heard the expression “cleanliness is next to Godliness”? In Mississippi, Godliness is next to incumbency, at least for Republicans and Benny Thompson. There are maybe 150 Republican-held seats that are pretty much locked in. Many of these are like Pickering, with no serious opposition. There’s another 20-25 that are almost as safe. With another 25 or so that the Republicans would only lose in a landslide of epic proportions, that’s bedrock of around 200 seats. Democrats probably also have a similar foundation of around 200 seats. So all the noise and smoke is about 35 or so House seats. Poll numbers for Democrats look very good on many of these. But the Republicans didn’t just get to where they are, and they haven’t stayed where they are, by luck. They can counter the emotion of the electorate with a well-oiled fundraising machine, a proven and massive get-out-the-vote effort, and strategists like Karl Rove who, however you feel about them, have proven time and again that they can effectively craft and distribute a message that resonates with a large segment of the population. The size of that segment is certainly smaller than in 2000, 2002, or 2004, but is it small enough to lose the elections? If you’re a Democrat, this isn’t the time to begin planning for a post-election victory party. Overconfidence could easily result in a Republican majority come November 8. Even if Democrats don’t suffer from overconfidence, even if the polls stay in their favor, they still could wind up winning fewer than 218 seats. And in the Senate, the opportunity for a Democratic takeover is even less. They have to win all of the toss-up races, and hold on to New Jersey. With George Allen in Virginia doing his best to lose, the chances are better than they were, but it’s still a reach. The Republicans have built a fortress, buttressed by organization and political skill and public relations. It’s been incredibly effective. This is, by far, it’s biggest challenge.

So what if the Democrats don’t make it? What if, after all the poll numbers, and the voter anger and disillusionment, and the Republican scandals, come November 8 the Republicans still hold 220 or so seatsa, and 51 or 52 Senate seats? You have to wonder how the Democratic Party goes forward if they don’t win control of at least the House. I can imagine massive bloodletting within the party if, after all the expectations, we’re left with a slightly weakened status quo. Republican moods will soar, Democrats will crash. It could get really, really ugly, and I’m not sure the Democratic Party could survive as more than a regional political organization. And with 2 1/2 weeks to go, I’m not ready to make any predictions.

This entry was posted in Politics. Bookmark the permalink.

4 Responses to Will The Fortress Hold?

  1. Jim says:

    WE NEED MORE KOOLAID!!!

  2. Brian S says:

    It is strange but, I was taught that Gerrymandering was illegal as a kid in civics class.

    What is it they call all these ‘locked in districts’ now-a-days?

  3. Dave says:

    Gerrymandering is a two-edged sword. By definition, diluting your opponent’s vote means cutting your lead in districts that favor your party. But if there’s an electoral sea change, that means you end up losing a lot of close elections.

    One of the things Dems are doing right now by following their “50 state” strategy is forcing Republicans to contest all those little districts that they used to hold by five or ten percentage points. I have a feeling the GOP may have over-gerrymandered in parts of the country where the Dems haven’t contested for a while, and with any luck, it will come back to bite them in the butt.

  4. Harry says:

    Dave, I hope you’re right. I’m trying not to get my hopes up. But it does look good.

Comments are closed.