At one time I would have put JFK at #1. He made Americans feel good about being Americans. But as I’ve had time to assess and reassess his presidency, my estimation of him has lowered. So here’s my rankings:
10. Bush 43. I think history will record his Presidency as a disaster. Reckless military intervention, government deceit, foolish fiscal policies, absurd health care policy.
9. Nixon. Bad economic policies, deliberate attempts to subvert the Constitution. He did, however, open the door to China.
8. Ford. Not a bad President, but in an unwinnable situation. I agreed and still agree with his pardon of Nixon, however. It had to be done.
7. Johnson. For all the bashing of LBJ, he was willing to set us on the path to a more fair and equitable country, even when he didn’t necessarily agree with it personally. Vietnam was his millstone, but he inherited what I now know was the JFK heritage there.
6. Carter. Everybody remembers 18% interest rates, and the Iran hostages. Nobody remembers the miniscule budget deficits, and the interest rate pressures he had no control over. And we’ve had plenty of chances to see how easy Middle East politics is.
5. Bush 41. He could have been one of the greatest Presidents. Certainly few were as prepared for the job. But he abandoned his own beliefs and ideas and sold out to the right wing of his party. Losing his re-election bid after GW I is the best indicator of his weaknesses.
4. John Kennedy. He made us dream big dreams. He also hid a potentially disastrous health condition from us. But the image of Camelot was a huge boost for Americans.
3. Reagan. His legacy of enormous budget deficits, and the near-dismantling of federal environmental agencies, and Iran-Contra are enough to knock him down.
2. Clinton. Welfare reform, budget surpluses, reduction in poverty levels, children’s health care initiatives are enough to outweigh oral sex. He out-Republicaned Republicans on some of their key yelling points, like welfare reform and deficit reduction. That really pissed them off.
1. Eisenhower. We drive on his biggest legacy every day, the interstate highway system. Steadiness during the worst of the Cold War. Restrained fiscal policies. The beginnings of Civil Rights intervention. He was the Joe Montana of US Presidents.
All those bad things about George W. Bush and he is still in the top 10? What does that say about all the other Presidents?
Personally I never saw the appeal to JFK. His first move in office was to invade a sovereign nation. Then he threatened to start a nuclear conflict if the Soviets did to the US what the US had been doing for a long time (surround it with nuclear weapons).
Everyone has their opinions, but I was disappointed not to see Abraham Lincoln anywhere in your list. Even if he isn’t one of your favourites, you have to concede he was one of the most influential and interesting, eh?
These are just the ones while I’ve been alive. If I were 155 years old, I would put Lincoln at the top!
My whole world started at Carter. Does that mean we have to choose between peanut farms and nuclear power plants?
Yours is a good list and it will make me ponder. Thanks.