Why The Warrantless Wiretapping Should Worry All Of Us

First, the facts, as much as can be determined: Immediately after the attacks of September 11, 2001, the US government was frantically trying to determine if more attacks were on the way. President Bush authorized the use of the National Security Agency’s eavesdropping capabilities – capabilities far beyond what most of us can imagine – to sift through telecommunications traffic moving around the world and into and out of the United States looking for information, without first asking for a warrant from the special Federal court set up to handle these matters. President Bush has admitted this, and that the order has been renewed every 45 days since the initial executive order.

This would appear to violate the 1978 Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Act – but in the immediate aftermath of 9/11, I can understand his action. In the immediate aftermath. The foreign intelligence oversight court acts fast, and has approved essentially all requests since it was established. But with cell phones being used and discarded almost immediately, I can buy the argument that there simply wasn’t time to determine what numbers needed to be tracked. Had I been President, I would likely have done the same thing. In the immediate aftermath. But to argue that the same necessity for immediacy continued to exist for over 4 years stretches the argument beyond legitimacy. However, that isn’t the trigger for my concern.

It is part of the paradigm of the fight against terrorism that the international drug trade and terrorist organizations are connected in a myriad of ways. Even if you just assume the two groups have a common disregard for the victims of their respective enterprises, there are pathways between the two. But the links between them go far beyond this. The drug trade is a source of enormous sums of money, and money is the grease that lubricates the gears of most terrorist organizations at some level. Whether some terrorists are masterminding drug trafficking in some locations is immaterial. Drug money is to some degree an enabling factor, and it’s a deliberately enabling factor in at least some cases. And that’s where my concern over the wiretaps lies.

The “War on Terror” is not a declared war. It lacks the formal declaration from Congress that would establish it as a truly special situation as far as actions by the US government are concerned. It is really nothing more than a label applied by President Bush – a label that’s warranted and appropriate, but nonetheless just a label. We have, at various times, had a similar “war on drugs” proclaimed by presidents at least as far back as Nixon. “War on drugs” was also a label proclaimed by the President. It’s perhaps farfetched to suggest that President Bush, or a future President of the United States, could claim the precedent of Bush’s actions regarding the wiretaps as justification to use wiretaps to “combat” the war on drugs. But in September of 2000, how many of us would have considered it lunacy to suggest that the US government would successfully seek the power to obtain library use data on US citizens without their knowledge or consent? At present, many conservatives are defending the President’s use of warrantless wiretaps to combat terrorism. But would, for instance, Rush Limbaugh, who has run afoul of US drug laws in the past, be as supportive of the right of the President to do this if his phone calls were wiretapped as part of a combined war on terror and drugs, especially if it were, say, President Hillary Clinton claiming the precedent? Because the “War on Terror” is not a formal war, it has no formal boundaries, and can essentially exist wherever and against whomever the government deems a terrorist or an ally of terrorists. It’s the repeated renewal of the executive order, justified by a cause that has at best an unclear definition, that should scare us. We are trading our freedom far too cheaply. We have mechanisms to legally allow the US government to use the incredible intelligence assets at its disposal in ways that potentially expose US citizens. We are, and always have been, a nation of laws. That’s what set us apart from most nations that have existed. We shouldn’t set that aside so lightly.

This entry was posted in Politics. Bookmark the permalink.