Cybernetics

I found myself today, and this evening, needing to undertake a fast-paced review of cybernetics – and quickly remembered why I’ve never invested much time learning about it. An overly simple definition of cybernetics might be “comparative study of biological and machine processes in order to understand how they’re alike and how they’re different“. And that’s nice, as far as it goes. But the problem with delving very deep into cybernetics is that it’s such a squishy field of knowledge. Or at least that’s what it seems like to me. Someone, maybe Dave, will come along and tell me I’m completely wrong about this. But cybernetics seems to be, on different days, a brother to, a mother to, or a distant cousin to, systems science, and operations research, and even queueing theory. I’m not sure any of those have a definition firm enough to withstand a convention of doctoral candidates in any of several quantitative fields. I remember during my college days reading about a division of the College of Engineering at my university called Systems Engineering. But when I asked my advisor about it, he couldn’t really tell me what they did there, much less whether any graduates actually found work. Not that it’s a useless endeavor. Indeed, we would have a certain prefix deficit without it. And how should we then adjectivize this wonderful information age in which we live? But the best, or at least my favorite, comment about cybernetics came from this website:

“It may be that we haven’t exhausted the potential of a science of communication and control, but I think at this point the burden of proof would be on the optimists.

Dissolved? Not entirely. There’s an old joke that if you’re not part of the solution, you’re part of the precipitate, and not everything associated with cybernetics has gone into solution. Caked on the bottom of the reaction vessel we find: A prefix which seems indispensible to marketroids; the occasion for a great deal of vaporizing in the social sciences and humanities; and a peculiarly navel-gazing sub-sect of systems theory, which isn’t exactly God’s gift to the advancement of learning in the first place.”

Going back to my non-original stab at a definition, it seems that the main thing cybernetics has taught us is that biological processes and machine processes, and social processes for that matter, aren’t sufficiently alike to engender any valid comparisons; or at least, maybe, that we aren’t yet smart enough to draw any valid comparisons.

This entry was posted in Geek Stuff. Bookmark the permalink.