The Two-Party Party

Since the election – since before the election – the left-leaning blogosphere has been in a state of constant murmur about the need for Democrats to re-evaluate, reprogram, reshape their image, their message, their policies. I joined in. Republicans are talking about a realignment of the US voting population. Some are proclaiming the beginning of a permanent conservative majority. One thing I feel safe in predicting is that they won’t achieve that. One thing that 200 years of democracy has taught us is that Americans are committed to a two-party system. If the Democrats can’t adjust their politics to something that voters want, voters will create a party to do that. Like I said just after the election:

the Democratic Party has to decide whether it’s a party dedicated to competing and winning political campaigns at the national and congressional level, or whether it’s just a collection of advocacy groups willing to settle for getting their issues discussed on the national stage. If it’s the former, then they have to develop a set of core issues and values that define them, and that resonate with the American voting public

History also say the Republican dominance won’t last long. That isn’t necessarily good news for Democrats, especially the more liberal groups within the party. The issues around which voters will coalesce may not be traditional liberal issues, although some will certainly be. Health care will certainly be a major part of the political debate over the next decade, and polls repeatedly show that Republican policies aren’t particularly popular. Education will continue to be very important to much of the voting population, and the increase of Federal intervention in the form of No Child Left Behind will draw much discussion. I expect environmentalism to reassert itself at some point, although not in the guise of the 1970s tree-hugger movement. And social security will be at the forefront of political campaigns for a long time to come.

Democrats can’t base their survival on a strategy of saying “No” to President Bush and Congressional Republicans. If ranting about how unfair Bush’s budget and policies are all they can do, then I have no use for them, and neither will the vast majority of the American people. If you don’t like the Bush budget, propose an opposition budget. And make it a serious budget, not just one that plays off of Republican cuts and increases. If you don’t like No Child Left Behind, propose something else. Sure, it will probably lose in both the House and the Senate. But when election time comes around, you’ll have something you can wave as an alternative you tried to push. If the things you propose are the same old things, you’ll quietly fade away, but at least you’ll know what you died of. I’m tired of hearing liberals espousing the European response – how could Americans have done such a stupid thing. They didn’t do a stupid thing, they picked the alternative they liked better, for whatever reason. If you don’t like what they chose, offer a better one next time around. It took Republican conservatives 16 years, from 1964 until 1980, to hone their message and find the right standard-bearer. It might take that long for Democrats to do the same. But it’s going to happen, and somebody will do it. History tells us that much.

(Beltway Traffic Jam)

This entry was posted in Politics. Bookmark the permalink.

One Response to The Two-Party Party

  1. Max says:

    I agree with you – Democrats must move back to being a national party. I must say, we have an odd couple right now – Harry Reid and Howard Dean – but they seem to know what they are doing, and Reid is more than holding his own as the Minority Leader. It’s going to be up to the rank and file, though, to pull us back together. The leadership can only do so much.

    The New Democrat

Comments are closed.