Buying Health Care

I’ve gotten embroiled in a mini-debate with Steve Verdon on Outside the Beltway over health care costs and access – well, it looks like a mini-debate from my side, anyway, I suspect from his perspective it’s more like a cat toying with it’s prey (I thought I was in a mini-debate, but my latest comments aren’t showing up on OTB). But I had a question that was going to make my comments far too long, and I didn’t want it to come off as a blog argument. I keep hearing how a system like Canada’s would explode health care costs here, and how we can’t afford universal health care. Now, I’m not necessarily saying we should have a Canadian-like system. But it just seems to me that we already pay a fortune for health care, and I wonder if we’re getting what we’re paying for. I’ve been looking for per-capita cost comparisons between the US and other countries, and here’s what I’ve found:

In 1998, the US spent $4178 per person. That’s the highest in the world. Switzerland is next at $2794, then Norway at $2425, Germany at $2424, and Canada at $2312. We spend a higher percentage of our GDP – 13.6% – versus 10.6% for Germany, Norway’s 8.9%, Canada’s 9,5%. And for all that, our infant mortality is significantly higher – 7.2, compared to Germany’s 4.9, and Canada’s 5.2.
Source: Bureau of Labor Education, University of Maine

I found another comparison, of health care administrative costs, between the US and Canada. This was in the New England Journal of Medicine in 2003 (abstract here), and reported that the US spent $1,059 per person on health care administrative costs, while Canada spent $307.

So – if other countries with universal or nationalized health care systems can do it with 60-70% of our per capita cost, why can’t we somehow do this? What’s making our obviously not-really-adequate system so expensive? Some are going to say lawsuit abuse. I’ve seen figures that estimate tort reform and the ensuing relief from lawsuit abuse could save as much ast $100 billion dollars – but we spend something like 1.4 trillion dollars, so that best case would only reduce costs by about 6%. We’d still be far, far above the costs of other countries.

So, I go back to my original question – are we getting what we’re paying for? There are something like 40 million uninsured. Providing these people with grants of $2500 per year to buy insurance would cost about 100 billion dollars. That sounds like a lot – until you realize that a savings of about 6% per year in our current health care costs would cover them. And since many of these are families who could group their insurance, the cost would probably be less. Now, I’m not proposing that this is a workable approach – it’s an overlysimplistic, off the cuff musing – just pointing out that we’re spending enough money now to provide health care coverage for every peron, if we could just figure out how to reallocate the expenditures.

(Beltway Traffic Jam)

This entry was posted in Politics, Healthcare. Bookmark the permalink.

2 Responses to Buying Health Care

  1. Chris S. says:

    Impressive thinking Harry. I

  2. Jammer says:

    I’d say there are two elements that drive this up. Well, maybe three. Okay, four. All right, five, but thats it, I promise!

    1. Other countries are free riders on the costs of US developed medications. So it is said, and its hard to argue against in the case of Canada, at least. Whether or not this is a matter of rent-seeking or truly necessary is an argument that is ongoing.

    2. Acute care. The US is extremely good at acute care. Its dealing with long-term issues that we are less good at. But that high-tech acute care gadgetry is expensive.

    3. Administration costs. Thousands of health care plans and insurers create a nightmare of billing, re-billing, and paperwork. It costs billions and billions to run this.

    4. Malpractive insurance *is* really high. The argument is how to fix it.

    5. That universal health care may be universal, but it can be dodgy and slow. The UK’s National Health Service is routinely castigated for suckage. I’ve spoken to Canadians who are not at all impressed with the way things work there.

    How’s that?

Comments are closed.